13F-HR 1 pzenainvestmentmg13fhr21072.txt HOLDINGS REPORT UNITED STATES SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION WASHINGTON, D.C. 20549 FORM 13F FORM 13F Cover Page Report for the Calendar Year or Quarter Ended: September 30, 2008 PZENA INVESTMENT MANAGEMENT, LLC -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Name of Institutional Investment Manager 120 West 45th Street, 20th Floor NY NY 10036 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Business Address (Street) (City) (State) (Zip) 13F File Number: 28-03791 -------------------- The Institutional Investment Manager filing this report and the person by whom it is signed hereby represent that the person signing the report is authorized to submit it, and that all information contained herein is true, correct and complete, and that it is understood that all required items, statements, schedules, and tables are considered integral parts of this form. Name, Title and Telephone Number of Person Submitting Report: Keith Komar Chief Administrative Officer (212) 355-1600 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Name (Title) (Phone) Signature, Place and Date of Signing: /s/Keith Komar -------------------------- Keith Komar, Chief Administrative Officer Pzena Investment Management, LLC 120 West 45th Street, 20th Floor New York, New York 10036 11/10/08 Report Type: [ ] 13F HOLDINGS REPORT [ ] 13F NOTICE [X] 13F COMBINATION REPORT Form 13F Summary Page Number of Other Included Managers: One (1) ------------------------ Form 13F Information Table Entry Total: 138 ------------------- Form 13F Information Table Value Total: $13,211,451,000 -------------------- List of Other Included Managers: Name and 13F file numbers of ALL Institutional Investment Managers with respect to which this schedule is filed (other than the one filing this report): (List in alphabetical order). 13F File No.: Name: ------------- --------------------- 028-12230 - ALPS Advisers, Inc. (1) Name of Reporting Manager: Pzena Investment Management, LLC AS OF DATE: 09/30/08

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ITEM 1 ITEM 2 ITEM 3 ITEM 4 ITEM 5 ITEM 6 ITEM 7 ITEM 8 FAIR INVESTMENT DISCRETION VOTING AUTHORITY TITLE MARKET SHARES OR SHARED NAME OF ISSUER OF CUSIP VALUE PRINCIPAL SOLE SHARED OTHER MANA- SOLE SHARED NONE CLASS NUMBER (x$1000) AMOUNT (A) (B) (C) GERS (A) (B) (C) ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ACE LTD COM H0023R105 662 12225 12225 0 0 12225 0 0 AFFILIATED COMPUTER SVCS IN COM 008190100 241138 4762746 4670521 0 92225 1 4011283 0 751463 ALCATEL-LUCENT COM 013904305 418929 109096083 107297250 0 1798833 1 96035633 0 13060450 ALLSTATE CORP COM 020002101 502082 10886437 10693312 0 193125 1 9308354 0 1578083 ALLSTATE CORP JAN 10 $60 CALL OPT 0000WLZAL 9 4000 4000 0 0 4000 0 0 AMER INTL GROUP COM 026874107 114 34350 34350 0 0 34350 0 0 AMER NATL INS COM 028591105 7011 81213 81213 0 0 62888 0 18325 AMERICAN EQUITY INVT LIFE COM 025676206 23288 3105024 3105024 0 0 2415874 0 689150 AMERISOURCEBERGEN CORP COM 03073E105 380013 10093314 9925601 0 167713 1 8681185 0 1412129 AMGEN INC COM 031162100 277550 4682808 4611708 0 71100 1 3979073 0 703735 ARGO GROUP INTERNATIONAL COM G0464B107 31075 843288 843288 0 0 575650 0 267638 ARTHUR J GALLAGHER & CO. COM 363576109 11383 443600 443600 0 0 359325 0 84275 ARVINMERITOR INC COM 043353101 9137 700700 700700 0 0 506375 0 194325 AT&T INC. COM 00206R102 691 24765 24765 0 0 24765 0 0 ATC TECHNOLOGY CORP COM 00211W104 19615 826230 826230 0 0 683470 0 142760 BANK OF AMERICA CORP COM 060505104 585527 16729344 16476419 0 252925 1 13931449 0 2797895 BED BATH & BEYOND INC COM 075896100 1265 40275 40275 0 0 40275 0 0 BLACK & DECKER COM 091797100 95758 1576264 1576264 0 0 1308414 0 267850 BLOUNT INTERNATIONAL COM 095180105 17202 1545514 1545514 0 0 1151064 0 394450 BOSTON SCIENTIFIC CORP COM 101137107 1117 91050 91050 0 0 91050 0 0 BOWNE & CO COM 103043105 760 65800 65800 0 0 50800 0 15000 BP PLC COM 055622104 156304 3115486 3029507 0 85979 1 2778407 0 337079 BRADY CORP COM 104674106 20946 593704 593704 0 0 479929 0 113775 BRISTOL-MYERS SQUIBB CO COM 110122108 335797 16105366 15858466 0 246900 1 13749041 0 2356325 CA INC. COM 12673P105 384217 19249371 18949171 0 300200 1 16345380 0 2903991 CAPITAL ONE FINL CORP COM 14040H105 723180 14180003 13988278 0 191725 1 11901087 0 2278916 CARDINAL HEALTH COM 14149Y108 298 6050 6050 0 0 6050 0 0 CARTER'S INC COM 146229109 36990 1874811 1874811 0 0 1570511 0 304300 CBS CORP COM 124857202 237 16225 16225 0 0 16225 0 0 CHEMICAL FINANCIAL CORP COM 163731102 31087 998311 998311 0 0 786536 0 211775 CHEVRON CORPORATION COM 166764100 391 4740 4740 0 0 4740 0 0 CHUBB CORP COM 171232101 707 12875 12875 0 0 12875 0 0 CIBER INC. COM 17163B102 22692 3246308 3246308 0 0 2521433 0 724875 CITIGROUP INC COM 172967101 802640 39134099 38632899 0 501200 1 32546795 0 6587304 COMERICA INC COM 200340107 225045 6863222 6734547 0 128675 1 5895297 0 967925 COMPUTER SCIENCES COM 205363104 12112 301358 301358 0 0 301358 0 0 CONSECO INC COM 208464883 8269 2349273 2349273 0 0 1891373 0 457900 CON-WAY INC COM 205944101 12561 284775 284775 0 0 212750 0 72025 COVIDIEN LTD COM G2552X108 358 6660 6660 0 0 6660 0 0 DEL MONTE FOODS COM 24522P103 26754 3430000 3430000 0 0 2803950 0 626050 DELL INC COM 24702R101 209 12669 12669 0 0 12669 0 0 DELPHI FINL GRP COM 247131105 31860 1136224 1136224 0 0 922221 0 214003 DISCOVER FINANCIAL COM 254709108 185 13416 13416 0 0 13416 0 0 DRESS BARN INC. COM 261570105 9647 630952 630952 0 0 466876 0 164076 EXXON MOBIL CORP COM 30231G102 15701 202177 202177 0 0 195327 0 6850 FANNIE MAE COM 313586109 30905 20199449 19927399 0 272050 1 16998525 0 3200924 FBL FINANCIAL GROUP INC. COM 30239F106 17553 629350 629350 0 0 498675 0 130675 FIDELITY NATIONAL FINANCIAL INC. COM 31620R105 151608 10313445 10059670 0 253775 1 9085118 0 1228327 FIRST AMERICAN CORP COM 318522307 35936 1218184 1218184 0 0 904416 0 313768 FIRST HORIZON NATIONAL CORP COM 320517105 2072 221350 221350 0 0 221350 0 0 FOREST LABS COM 345838106 66 2330 2330 0 0 2330 0 0 FREDDIE MAC COM 313400301 53794 31458219 30985469 0 472750 1 26518534 0 4939685 GRIFFON CORPORATION COM 398433102 26353 2921599 2921599 0 0 2225373 0 696226 GRIFFON CORPORATION-RTS COM 398433110 4 53318 53318 0 0 48904 0 4414 HANGER ORTHOPEDIC COM 41043F208 2128 121954 121954 0 0 40679 0 81275 HARMAN INTL COM 413086109 7750 227475 227475 0 0 188200 0 39275 HARTE-HANKS, INC. COM 416196103 22507 2170425 2170425 0 0 1684600 0 485825 HASBRO INC COM 418056107 1269 36562 36562 0 0 670 0 35892 HILB ROGAL & HOBBS CO COM 431294107 6335 135539 135539 0 0 91014 0 44525 HOME DEPOT INC COM 437076102 423146 16343998 16101848 0 242150 1 14033826 0 2310172 HSBC HOLDINGS PLC COM 404280406 9349 115665 115665 0 0 15771 0 99894 IDACORP INC COM 451107106 3137 107833 107833 0 0 82858 0 24975 IMS HEALTH INCORPORATED COM 449934108 68209 3607059 3607059 0 0 2757759 0 849300 ING GROEP N.V. COM 456837103 7613 355750 355750 0 0 5575 0 350175 INTUIT INC COM 461202103 318 10075 10075 0 0 10075 0 0 IPC HOLDINGS LTD COM G4933P101 33686 1115049 1115049 0 0 885399 0 229650 J.C. PENNEY CO. INC. COM 708160106 350569 10514964 10340964 0 174000 1 9067210 0 1447754 JOHNSON & JOHNSON COM 478160104 367402 5303146 5222871 0 80275 1 4561975 0 741171 JONES APPAREL GROUP INC COM 480074103 25830 1395482 1395482 0 0 1081682 0 313800 JP MORGAN CHASE & CO COM 46625H100 463622 9927669 9736794 0 190875 1 8537569 0 1390100 KB FINANCIAL GROUP INC COM 48241A105 7981 174675 174675 0 0 150050 0 24625 KELLY SERVICES INC COM 488152208 29942 1571764 1571764 0 0 1299143 0 272621 KIMBERLY-CLARK CORPORATION COM 494368103 216127 3333241 3297141 0 36100 1 3017680 0 315561 KOHLS CORP COM 500255104 130287 2827413 2766813 0 60600 1 2390375 0 437038 KOREA ELEC POWER CORP COM 500631106 7263 586200 586200 0 0 392800 0 193400 KRAFT FOODS INC COM 50075N104 111221 3396070 3275620 0 120450 1 2693670 0 702400 L-3 COMMUNICATIONS COM 502424104 168695 1715779 1690479 0 25300 1 1501512 0 214267 LEAR CORP COM 521865105 65088 6198870 6198870 0 0 4623075 0 1575795 LIZ CLAIBORNE INC COM 539320101 316 19225 19225 0 0 19225 0 0 LOWES COS INC COM 548661107 24459 1032470 1032470 0 0 889425 0 143045 MI DEVELOPMENTS INC. COM 55304X104 16721 904347 904347 0 0 761047 0 143300 MAGNA INTL INC. COM 559222401 278353 5437640 5342290 0 95350 1 4738215 0 699425 MATTEL INC COM 577081102 152117 8432181 8235506 0 196675 1 6916707 0 1515474 MCKESSON CORPORATION COM 58155Q103 326 6050 6050 0 0 6050 0 0 MERCER INSURANCE GROUP COM 587902107 216 13425 13425 0 0 13425 0 0 MERCK & CO. INC. COM 589331107 182517 5783162 5662387 0 120775 1 5071487 0 711675 METLIFE INC COM 59156R108 1011 18057 18057 0 0 18057 0 0 MICROSOFT CORP COM 594918104 468687 17560379 17253404 0 306975 1 14920929 0 2639450 MILACRON INC COM 598709301 159 151366 151366 0 0 110579 0 40787 MITSUBISHI UFJ FINL GRP COM 606822104 12812 1465925 1465925 0 0 211950 0 1253975 MOODY'S CORP COM 615369105 8591 252691 252691 0 0 241416 0 11275 MORGAN STANLEY COM 617446448 147461 6411334 6300909 0 110425 1 5472086 0 939248 MOTOROLA INC. COM 620076109 228282 31972279 31367254 0 605025 1 27243022 0 4729257 NARA BANCORP INC COM 63080P105 17823 1591315 1591315 0 0 1236340 0 354975 NATIONAL CITY CORP COM 635405103 123843 70767372 69948085 0 819287 1 59081013 0 11686359 NCI BLDG SYS INC COM 628852105 12951 407893 407893 0 0 305618 0 102275 NORTHROP GRUMMAN CORP COM 666807102 367515 6070615 5957090 0 113525 1 5239689 0 830926 OLD REPBLC INTL COM 680223104 66413 5208877 5208877 0 0 3825573 0 1383304 ORACLE CORP COM 68389X105 1108 54577 54577 0 0 54577 0 0 PEDIATRIX MEDICAL GROUP, INC. COM 705324101 2492 46220 46220 0 0 21270 0 24950 PFIZER INC COM 717081103 42593 2309789 2309789 0 0 1747714 0 562075 PHARMANET DEVELOPMENT GROUP INC COM 717148100 4438 614675 614675 0 0 493875 0 120800 PHH CORP COM 693320202 22903 1723304 1723304 0 0 1339204 0 384100 PIKE ELECTRIC CORPORATION COM 721283109 16711 1134504 1134504 0 0 885854 0 248650 PLANTRONICS, INC. COM 727493108 20800 923636 923636 0 0 720361 0 203275 PNM RESOURCES INC COM 69349H107 16153 1577425 1577425 0 0 1180600 0 396825 POPULAR INC. COM 733174106 131826 15901863 15901863 0 0 12563445 0 3338418 PROTECTIVE LIFE CORP COM 743674103 7748 271750 271750 0 0 232300 0 39450 RADIO ONE INC. COM 75040P405 1568 2090725 2090725 0 0 1644250 0 446475 REGIS CORP COM 758932107 36066 1311482 1311482 0 0 1057907 0 253575 RENAISSANCE RE HLDGS LTD COM G7496G103 215852 4150996 4150996 0 0 3261566 0 889430 RENT A CENTER INC COM 76009N100 111077 4985511 4985511 0 0 3713111 0 1272400 ROYAL BANK OF SCOTLAND COM 780097721 76 23600 23600 0 0 0 0 23600 SARA LEE CORP COM 803111103 141253 11183907 10943761 0 240146 1 9897525 0 1286382 SCHERING PLOUGH COM 806605101 166433 9011010 8887535 0 123475 1 7612169 0 1398841 SCHWEITZER MAUDUIT INTL I COM 808541106 17417 917159 917159 0 0 800069 0 117090 SEALY CORPORATION COM 812139301 16751 2592975 2592975 0 0 2050375 0 542600 SEMPRA ENERGY COM 816851109 319735 6335156 6253906 0 81250 1 5438751 0 896405 SPHERION CORPORATION COM 848420105 7978 1638257 1638257 0 0 1258707 0 379550 STEWART INFORMATION SERVICES COM 860372101 4722 158713 158713 0 0 116738 0 41975 TECH DATA CORP COM 878237106 25682 860354 860354 0 0 693979 0 166375 TIMBERLAND CO COM 887100105 8866 510400 510400 0 0 405100 0 105300 TIME WARNER INC COM 887317105 521 39775 39775 0 0 39775 0 0 TJX COS INC NEW COM 872540109 53403 1749780 1749780 0 0 1415203 0 334577 TORCHMARK CORP COM 891027104 365133 6105911 5984786 0 121125 1 5278929 0 826982 TREX COMPANY COM 89531P105 20533 1133821 1133821 0 0 944496 0 189325 TYCO ELECTRONICS LTD COM G9144P105 32328 1168775 1168775 0 0 1168775 0 0 TYCO INTL LTD COM G9143X208 48310 1379511 1379511 0 0 1315652 0 63859 UBS AG ADR COM H89231338 7932 452218 412568 0 39650 1 362193 0 90025 UNITED AMERICA INDEMNITY - A COM 90933T109 23171 1612474 1612474 0 0 1276317 0 336157 UNITED STATIONERS INC COM 913004107 13288 277824 277824 0 0 218799 0 59025 UNIVERSAL CORP COM 913456109 9319 189831 189831 0 0 152756 0 37075 VIACOM INC CL B COM COM 92553P201 1560 62822 62822 0 0 62822 0 0 VIAD CORP NEW COM 92552R406 10403 361327 361327 0 0 282654 0 78673 WACHOVIA CORP COM 929903102 114097 32598732 32099407 0 499325 1 27362984 0 5235748 WAL-MART STORES COM 931142103 64846 1082750 1082750 0 0 815421 0 267329 WHIRLPOOL CORP COM 963320106 404600 5102788 5033338 0 69450 1 4348783 0 754005 WISCONSIN ENERGY COM 976657106 253645 5649098 5553573 0 95525 1 4971348 0 677750 XL CAPITAL LTD COM G98255105 7263 404857 390258 0 14599 1 353411 0 51446